Feeling less alone…

Big BrotherI’ve written before about Harvard’s Orwellian reaction to my book – threatening letters, demeaning remarks to other journalists, advising students and faculty not to read it etc. etc. – but I’m feeling less alone these days.

In an article in the June Harvard Business Review a former professor of mine, Joel Podolny, says he quibbles with some of my criticisms but shares my frustration with the MBA as it is today. Joel recently left his job as dean of Yale’s School of Management to join Apple, as the founding dean of Apple University. (He even writes that I was “one of the better students” he taught at HBS, which is a relief.)

Also, Tom Peters, the author of In Search of Excellence is a gleeful critic of MBAs, and the extraordinary knots they are tying themselves in at the moment. Peters is wonderfully scornful of Jack Welch, a man I always thought was sort of an ass, but at least a successful one. That changed when Welch came to talk at HBS, when I concluded he was actually an embarrassment. And yet still, he’s idolized and is setting up his own online MBA program. Run, don’t walk, from that one.

Robert Joss, the departing dean of Stanford’s business school acknowledges in a farewell letter that a “better balance is needed” at MBA programs. He notes that the latest graduating class “will experience a closing Synthesis Seminar developed by faculty experts in organizational behavior, trust, leadership, management, and finance. The purpose of this final seminar is to have students reflect on what they have learned and what values and goals they want to live by—so they are better prepared to deal with the many gray areas and difficult decisions they will face. My hope is that they will be leaders with confidence (not hubris) and compassion, mindful of the results of their decisions on the people whose trust they must earn: employees, customers, community members, and investors.”

It sounds good, but it’s the same problem. MBA programs and business leaders more broadly talk about good behavior as if it’s some kind of amazing discovery – see Corporate Social Responsibility – whereas everyone else regards it as simply to be expected. So they end up, quite rightly, as objects of ridicule.

3 thoughts on “Feeling less alone…

  1. Deborah Exo

    Heartening to hear that there are some cracks in the MBA-grind-them-out degrees. Many of us who are boomers are very unhappy with the legacy we are leaving our children….this is one of those legacies that we created with the best of intent, which served its purpose for a time and now is contributing in many ways to its demise. We needs a new construct of learning that addresses the 21st century!


  2. Emma

    Being a business school professor myself, I must say that I LOVED your book. I will definitely make it compulsory reading for my students this fall.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s