Goldman Sachs: $21 billion – America’s homeless: $1.5 billion

There are so many ways to look at what’s happened in the US economy over the past year. But I think the best way is to look at how unequal the recovery has been. The growing income gap was apparent before the recession. But the nature of the government’s approach, and the extraordinary behavior of the banks has only exacerbated it. It goes to the heart of why the behavior of Goldman Sachs and the other banks still feasting on cheap government backed debt is so unpleasant.

To take Goldman. It has raised $21 billion of capital by issuing debt insured by the government – on the principle that this money would help stimulate the broader economy. Goldman gets to borrow cheaply, courtesy of the US government, then invest to make healthy returns. It then uses these returns to pay its employees and stock-holders. Has any of this helped unglue the credit markets for ordinary Americans? Hardly. Has it helped Goldman? Yes. Tremendously. Anyone able to borrow cheaply and invest over the past year would have done exceedingly well.

Meanwhile, small businesses and employees have been left to go to hell. This article in the New York Times about the rise in teenage runaways over the past two years is especially galling. Of the $787 billion stimulus plan approved earlier this year, $1.5 billion is going to homeless problems. That’s less than Warren Buffett will make on the Goldman investment he made last year.

I know exactly what Goldman’s supporters will say. Come on. You can’t blame us for everything that ails this country. No. But one can blame them for contributing mightily to the social and economic discordance everyone beyond Wall Street can feel. One can blame them for shoving their own interests to the top of the government’s to-do list, using their Washington muscle and bogus threats about the collapse of the entire economic system, then lining their own pockets.

Goldman, J.P.Morgan et al. have made the economy feel like a zero-sum game. Their actions have consequences which ripple down to the very lowest levels of society. During boom times, this seems less obvious. But at times like these, when borrowing, even for the US government, is so tough, it’s glaringly apparent that the money Wall Street has is money the teen runaways and homeless don’t have.

Go on, Goldman. Do something about it.


3 thoughts on “Goldman Sachs: $21 billion – America’s homeless: $1.5 billion

  1. Felix

    Well said, Philip! The older I get, the more I do think that society is, to a large extent, a zero-sum game. The whole notion of “trickle-down” is a farce.

    Which reminds me, I also think the economic concept of “comparative advantage” is also a convenient excuse used to justify exploitation of third-world countries. Peru, you make t-shirts, while we, the USA, we’ll make computers. And in the end, we will both be prosperous countries!


  2. Aditya

    Though what you write is very true and the way financial institutions are behaving even now, is very disgusting ; Goldman Sachs would say what Henry said after Ireland-France qualifier last weekend ‘Yes, there was a hand, but I’m not the referee’.

    US Govt and other govts in other parts of the world have failed to understand the real threat to economy, sufficiently penalise and reform the culprits and so indeed the buck stops there. A business is profit centred but not the Govt. Citizens expect a Govt to have a robust moral compass.


  3. Hi Mr. Broughton. I think that the government should’ve monitored exactly as to which companies Goldman Sachs was investing. Investing in already blue-chip firms will not help “stimulate” the economy, but investments in small and medium businesses definitely would. At least that’s what the government naively hoped that Goldman’s army of MBA grads would do. But alas ! Once an i-banker, always an i-banker.

    I’m halfway through reading your book currently, and its a very good read.

    Thank you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s